What we can learn from the BCS

Posted December 13, 2012


What we can learn from the BCS

Growing weary of winter expansion talk, I let this be my final thoughts on the whole expansion debate.

Grumblings of the ridiculousness of 2-3 hour drives for games seemed to be prominent. Travel is a concern and weekday games are nice when it comes to tradition and planning out your summers.

One idea I pondered in the dead of winter 2011 was to learn what an organization did to mathematically calculate the differences between small conferences and leagues during a relatively short season and playoffs. Who am I talking about?

NCAA Football. The BCS. The Bowl Championship Series.

With expansion unlikely. What about a province-wide or North Central wide ranking system purely based on mathematics, using strength of schedule, home-away, tournament and exhibition games and playoffs to come up with a final ranking at the end of the season.

Leagues would be encouraged to post teams’ non-conference games and submit scores to someone to tabulate standings and percentages overall. I’m a geek so I could nominate myself.

The goal being to promote more non-conference games, whether it’s tournaments or exhibition games, and to see comparisons between teams. It could even create the hunger to play similarly-ranked teams for bragging rights at the end of the year.

The formula would take into account beyond wins and losses:

  • Strength of schedule
  • Tournament, league or exhibition game
  • Location of game (Home/Away/Neutral)
  • Class of opponent (AAA/AA/A)
  • Score (Not pure runs for or against, but levels for shutouts and >10 runs, etc…


At the end of the season a ranking could be done. Those that may want to participate could play off in a bowl-like format or the top teams could get invites to provincials at a reduced rate.

Crazy idea? Probably. But once the formula is figured out, it’d be fun to track for us data geeks.

 

Photos
2016 Season
2016 Season
2016 Season
2016 Season
2016 Season
2018 Semi-Finals - Leduc vs Rosalind
2017 Season
2016 Season
2016 Season
2017 PBL Championship